Reservations & Dining

How do I make a restaurant reservation?

Making restaurant reservations on Staten Island is easy. Simply reserve your table online using our reservation system or give Millie's of Staten Island a call. We recommend booking in advance to secure your preferred date and time, especially on weekends and holidays.

Make a Reservation
Do I need a reservation to dine at Millie's Old World?

While walk-ins are always welcome when seating is available, we highly recommend making a reservation, especially during weekends, holidays, and peak dining hours. Reserving your table helps ensure a smooth and enjoyable dining experience.

Make a Reservation
Do you accept same-day reservations?

Yes! Same-day reservations are accepted based on availability. For the best selection of dining times, we recommend reserving your table as early as possible, especially for evenings and weekends.

Make a Reservation
Can I make a reservation for a large group or special occasion?

Absolutely! We welcome reservations for birthdays, anniversaries, business dinners, family gatherings, and other special occasions. If you're planning a larger party, please contact us in advance so we can accommodate your group and provide the best possible experience.

Make a Reservation
Can I request a specific table or seating area?

We'll do our best to accommodate seating requests whenever possible. While specific tables cannot be guaranteed, our team will make every effort to provide seating that best fits your preferences and party size when making your restaurant reservation on Staten Island.

Make a Reservation

Menu

Where can I see the menu?

Our full menu is online, with Appetizers, Meatballs, Salads, Sandwiches, Platters, Pasta, Entrees, Sides, Pizza, Take Home, Dessert, Beverages and Happy Hour.

View the Menu
What is Millie's Old World known for?
Can I order online?

Yes. Online orders for Millie's of Staten Island are placed through Toast.

Order Online

Catering & Events

What types of events do you cater?

Millie's of Staten Island provides Italian catering for corporate events, weddings, birthday parties, holiday gatherings, graduations, rehearsal dinners, family reunions, office lunches, and other special occasions. Whether you're hosting an intimate gathering or a large celebration, we'll help create the perfect catering menu for your event.

About Our Catering
How far in advance should I place my catering order?

We recommend placing your catering order as early as possible to ensure availability, especially for weddings, holidays, and large events. However, we'll always do our best to accommodate last-minute requests whenever possible.

About Our Catering
Can you accommodate large parties and corporate events?

Absolutely! Our Italian catering on Staten Island is perfect for everything from small family gatherings to large corporate meetings, weddings, and private celebrations. We'll work with you to customize a catering package that fits your guest count, menu preferences, and budget.

About Our Catering
What items are included on your catering menu?

Our catering menu features many of the signature dishes guests love, including 3-foot sandwiches, starters, fresh salads, meatballs and Italian entrées, homemade pasta, our 42 oz dry-aged porterhouse and our signature Pot of Balls®. Small trays feed 12 and large trays feed 24.

View the Catering Menu

Locations

Where is Millie's Old World located?

Millie's of Staten Island is located at 185 Bricktown Way, Staten Island, NY 10309, an easy destination for lunch, dinner, events, and special occasions.

Get Directions
What are your hours on Staten Island?

Monday – Thursday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM. Friday – Saturday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM. Sunday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM.

Visit or Contact Us
How can I reach the Staten Island restaurant?

Call us at (929) 284-4004 or email contact@milliesoldworld.com.

Visit or Contact Us
Do you have more than one location?

Yes. Millie's Old World serves guests at our Italian restaurants in Staten Island, New York and Morristown, New Jersey.

Visit or Contact Us

LET’S WORK OUT THE DETAILS

Something else on your mind?

For a question about your visit, get in touch with our team.

Let's Connect Today!

Design preview

This destination is part of a future stage. Policies, contact details, social profiles, page destinations, reservations and online ordering have not been connected yet.